Earned Authority: The Leadership TouchPoints That Build, or Break, Trust in the First 90 Days

From TouchPoints: Moments that Matter in Healthcare · 39:45

Show by Melissa Gilkes-Smith

Send us Fan MailFeaturing Neill Marshall and Kurt Mosley of HealthSearch PartnersThe announcement has gone out. The title is official. A new healthcare leader has arrived.But employees are already asking questions the hiring process cannot answer: Will this person listen? Will they understand what we are dealing with? Will their actions match their promises?The title provides authority. What happens next determines whether the leader earns trust.In this episode of TouchPoints: Moments that Matter in Healthcare, host Melissa Gilkes-Smith welcomes Neill Marshall and Kurt Mosley of HealthSearch Partners to explore Earned Authority™ and the leadership touchpoints that shape a new executive’s first 90 days. The conversation examines the distinction between having the authority to make decisions and earning the credibility, relationships, and trust needed to lead effectively. Drawing on decades of healthcare executive search and leadership transition experience, Neill and Kurt bring complementary perspectives: what organizations need when selecting a leader, and what that leader must understand after arriving. Melissa connects both to a central question for the podcast: How does the way employees experience leadership shape the care patients ultimately experience? What organizations are really hiring forA position description can outline responsibilities and qualifications. But what does it reveal about the organization’s culture, unresolved tensions, or expectations that have never been clearly stated?The conversation begins with the gap between what organizations say they want in a new executive and what they actually need. Melissa, Neill, and Kurt explore cultural alignment, relationship-building, and the emotional landscape of a team in transition.A new leader may see an opportunity for a fresh start. Employees may be carrying hope, skepticism, and memories of promises previous leaders did not keep. This discussion asks how executives can understand that history before trying to change the organization’s direction. Title gives authority. Behavior earns trust.What does earning authority look like in everyday interactions?Melissa and her guests examine leadership presence, visibility, and the difference between relying on a title and demonstrating credibility through behavior. The focus is on how leaders show up in meetings, move through the organization, and engage with the people delivering care.The episode also revisits Leadership by Walking Around, asking what a new executive should be listening to and looking for during those first weeks. Beyond being seen, how can leaders use that presence to understand staff dynamics, operational friction, and the culture their teams experience? Understanding the room before trying to move itThe conversation introduces the 25/50/25 principle as a framework for discussing how teams respond to a new direction: early supporters, those who resist, and a middle group still deciding whether the leader is worth following.Rather than assuming that everyone will immediately embrace a new vision, the episode explores how leaders earn credibility with people who are watching and waiting. What can a small, early action communicate? How should a leader approach resistance? And how can an early win build confidence without becoming a rushed attempt to prove that change is happening?The underlying tension is practical: How do you demonstrate momentum without moving before you understand the organization? Listening for organizational whispersFormal briefings provide one view of an organization. Hallway conversations, shift handoffs, and interactions with frontline teams can reveal another.Melissa and her guests explore “organizational whispers”—the informal information that may never reach an executive through established reporting channels. The discussion asks how leaders move beyond a carefully presented organizational narrative to understand what employees are experiencing.It also considers the uncomfortable realization some executives encounter months into a role: I didn’t know what I was walking into. What cultural dynamics, legacy conflicts, and staff concerns were not visible during the interview process? And how can a new leader begin uncovering them earlier? After listening comes the test: Follow-throughA leader holds listening sessions, asks thoughtful questions, and takes notes. Employees begin to hope that this time will be different.Then what?This episode examines the follow-through gap: the distance between asking for input and demonstrating that the input mattered. Melissa, Neill, and Kurt explore the small, consistent actions that communicate responsiveness, along with the importance of acknowledging the skepticism created by previous leadership experiences. The discussion also addresses what happens when a leader cannot deliver everything employees want. How can executives communicate constraints honestly rather than allowing silence to become the message?And…

More episodes of TouchPoints: Moments that Matter in Healthcare

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.