DOJ Sues to Block Alaska’s Senate Results if Sullivan Loses, Meta’s $25B Penalty Faces Appeal & How SCOTUS Reshaped the Midterms
From Minimum Competence · 7:45
Show by Andrew and Gina Leahey
This Day in Legal History: The O.K. CorralOn October 26, 1881, in Tombstone, in the Arizona Territory, City Marshal Virgil Earp, his brothers Wyatt and Morgan, and Doc Holliday confronted a group of cowboys, including Ike and Billy Clanton and Tom and Frank McLaury, near the O.K. Corral. The gunfight lasted about thirty seconds. Billy Clanton and both McLaurys were killed. Virgil, Morgan, and Holliday were wounded.The legend tends to end there, but the legal story is just as interesting. Days later, Ike Clanton filed murder charges against the Earps and Holliday. Wyatt and Doc were arrested and released on $10,000 bail. Justice of the Peace Wells Spicer then held a month-long preliminary hearing, with dueling witnesses: the county sheriff testified that the cowboys had tried to surrender, while other witnesses, including some considered neutral, testified that the cowboys had drawn first. On November 30, Spicer ruled there wasn’t enough evidence to send the case to trial. He found the lawmen acted within the law, though he criticized Virgil Earp’s judgment in deputizing his brothers and Holliday. The ruling didn’t end the feud. Within months, Virgil was ambushed and Morgan was killed.The significance of October 26, 1881 is that even the most mythologized act of frontier violence ended up before a judge, and what happened next turned on evidence, witnesses, and legal standards. The phrase in today’s opening quote, often attributed to Lincoln, captures the idea that in a democracy, disputes are settled by votes and by law rather than force. That idea is at the center of everything we cover today, as the courts take on an unusually large role in the run-up to the election.The Justice Department has sued Alaska election officials in federal court in Anchorage, asking a judge to block certification of the state’s U.S. Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan loses. The President said he ordered the suit: “I’m the one that said, ‘do it.’” The theory is unusual. Another candidate on the ballot is also named Daniel Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan, and the department argues his candidacy could confuse voters and violates the National Voter Registration Act. It’s asking the court to bar certification if Sen. Sullivan doesn’t win and certain other conditions are met. The race between Sullivan and Democrat Mary Peltola is close. Legal experts describe the lawsuit as without precedent and facing an uphill battle. Here’s why. First, timing. Courts are generally very reluctant to change election rules close to an election, and this suit was filed 11 days before Election Day, months after the ballot was finalized. If there was a problem with the ballot, the time to raise it was before ballots were printed and mailed. Second, the statute. The National Voter Registration Act governs voter registration, things like registering at the DMV and keeping voter rolls accurate. It doesn’t regulate who can appear on a ballot or how candidates’ names are listed. That’s governed by state law. Third, the remedy. Asking a court to block certification only if one particular candidate loses is unusual, to put it mildly. Courts decide legal questions based on the claims, not on which side wins. And states, not the federal government, run and certify their elections, with Congress, here the Senate, having its own role in judging its members’ elections. Even Alaska’s other Republican senator, Lisa Murkowski, said the department “should never have filed this lawsuit,” and reports indicate the attorney general has acknowledged that blocking certification would be unlikely outside extreme circumstances.Trump administration sues to block Senate race certification in Alaska if Republican loses | Reuters · Alaska Public Media · VotebeatLast week, New Mexico state Judge Francis Mathew ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in the Cambridge Analytica case, and Reuters reports legal experts believe Meta has a strong chance of getting it reduced on appeal. Recall the background we’ve been tracking. In September, a Santa Fe jury found Meta violated New Mexico’s Unfair Practices Act more than 43 million times by misleading residents about how their Facebook data was handled. The statute allows up to $5,000 per violation, which put the theoretical maximum at about $219 billion. New Mexico asked for $35 to $40 billion; Meta asked the judge to cap it at $3.45 billion. The judge landed at $25 billion. Meta says it will appeal, that the ruling makes it nearly impossible to do business in New Mexico, and that the suit effectively imposes a “tax on speech.” Here’s why experts think the number is vulnerable. The Eighth Amendment’s Excessive Fines Clause applies to civil penalties paid to a government, and the Supreme Court held in Timbs v. Indiana that it applies to the states. A fine violates that clause if it is “grossly disproportional” to the offense. Courts also apply due-process limits to very large awards. And New Mexico’s appellate courts will review whether…
More episodes of Minimum Competence
More episodes
- Gibson Dunn Lands Weil’s 120-Lawyer Funds Team, the Senate Calls Jensen Huang and Howard Lutnick & SEC and CFTC Nominees Head to the Senate
- Remembering Judge Richard Posner & Alaska’s Ballot-Data Fight in the Last Uncalled Senate Race
- Weil’s Lawyers Scatter, Anthropic Faces a Suit Over Claude Max Marketing & the Paper Trail Behind Florida’s New Property Tax Cut
- A Defeated Texas Justice Heads for the Federal Bench, a Judge Halts Trump’s Arch & Legal Jobs Hit a Record High
- A Kentucky Law Professor’s Free-Speech Fight, Big Tech Sues Over California’s Youth Social Media Law & the Battle Over Trump’s Triumphal Arch
- Democrats Win Congress: What Divided Government Can and Can’t Do, Kraft Heinz Sells Maxwell House & the NYT Sues Brave
- SCOTUS Ends Trump’s Bid to Freeze California Ballots, a Judge Blocks Federal Noncitizen-Voter Lists & Why Refund-Heavy Tax Preparers Shouldn’t Be Red Flags
- Weil Gotshal Plans to Dissolve, the US Sues Google Over a Returning Reservist & the White House Press Fight Moves to the Oval Office
- A Judge Weighs the 20,000 Disputed California Ballots, SCOTUS Lets Shelved Deportation Cases Return & Fixing the Multistate Sales Tax Disclosure Pilot
- The Ninth Circuit Rebuffs DOJ on California Ballots, a Judge Says Maurene Comey Was Unlawfully Fired & James Comey Is Charged a Third Time
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.