Ross Douthat Worships A God Of Cruelty
From Not Everyone Believes Ross Douthat · 00:30:15
Show by Clifford Cook
In the latest chapter of his book, Ross Douthat twists and turns to justify suffering as a good thing, because it comes from his god. He runs away from a confrontation with the brutal cruelty of the Christian deity, making excuses without any reasonable throughline.It's another episode of Not Everyone Believes, Ross Douthat. This podcast reads and examines, with a critical perspective, which means that we're not taking it for granted that the author is just right about everything. We're actually thinking about what's being said. We're examining the book Believe: Why Everyone Should Be Religious. This is a book that's written by right wing Christian Nationalist extremist political commentator Ross Douthat.At every step along the way so far, Ross Douthat has failed to provide a rational kind of justification for his religious beliefs in particular and for religion in general.Now, we're going ahead to chapter 6, which has the title Three Stumbling Blocks. These are three stumbling blocks specifically for Christianity.It's a weird order for this to be covered in chapter 6 because Ross Douthat places his most concentrated argument for Christianity in his final chapter, but this comes first.That tells you everything you need to know about this book. The book is actually an argument for Christianity all the way through. In this chapter, Ross Douthat is attempting to make a demonstration that he is actually considering a few arguments against Christianity. That's why we have the title Three Stumbling blocks for this chapter.The 1st stumbling block that he's going to decimate, he's going to show why it's not an impediment at all, is this: Why Does God Allow So Many Wicked Things To Happen?That's the title, word for word: Why Does God Allow So Many Wicked Things To Happen? That phrasing of the title shows you what Ross Douthat is up to here.Ross Douthat is offering this objection to Christianity only in its most mild version. Actual objections to Christianity include a much stronger version, which is Why does God do so many wicked things to people?If there is a Christian God, why would anyone want to worship that God?Let's just put reality off to the side. Ross Douthat has already failed completely to provide any rational basis for belief in the reality of any God, much less the Christian God. Nonetheless, Douthat is now arguing that his Christian God is actually moral, even though this is a God that has all the power in the universe to make things right, and fails to do it.More than that, we have in the Christian text itself, throughout Old Testament and New Testament, many examples of the Christian God, doing things that are absolutely cruel, violent, and small-minded in its violence. This Christian God, at the end of the Christian New Testament, promises to do even worse, to kill off huge portions of humanity, the vast majority of humans on the planet, in really nasty ways, torturing them first, just so that this god can then rule over the earth.It's weird. It's violent. It’s a terrible moral example.Ross Douthat won't confront that objection to Christianity. Honestly, I mean, how could he?Instead, he's only dealing with this weaker question of like, why does God simply allow wicked things to happen? Why doesn't the Christian God stop other people from doing wicked things?At this point, Douthat brings up Christopher Hitchens, because, you know, another thing Douthat loves to do. He loves to restrict his ideas of atheism to what he calls the New Atheists, who are actually just a few recent atheists. There's no difference between New Atheism and plain old atheism anyway.Douthat is bringing up an argument that's been made by many people well before “New Atheists” came on the scene maybe 20 years ago. That argument is that if he Christian God is all powerful and bad things are happening, then therefore, the Christian God could stop those bad things, but chooses not to, therefore, this Christian God is either not all powerful or not all good.Of course, the most rational explanation is that the Christian god doesn't exist at all, simply because it's a ludicrous idea that there is a magical being who is invisible, who never shows up, but we're supposed to believe in anyway.Obviously, there's a lot of nastiness in the world. Why, if there's an all powerful and benevolent divinity who could undo at all, has this god chosen to keep all of humanity in pain?On page 155, Ross Douthat begins to attempt to respond to this long-lasting criticism of Christianity by talking about what the philosophical basis for making moral judgments.Ross Douthat questions the idea that human beings have the ability to judge what's good and evil. He says that this objection, “assumes that we can identify good and evil as meaningful categories at all, as exposed to just flags of convenience for things to instinctively favor and dislike.”Ross Douthat is arguing that if you only have human judgment about what is morally right or wrong, then it's…
More episodes of Not Everyone Believes Ross Douthat
More episodes
- Ross Douthat Admits Christianity Is Cruel But Chooses It Anyway. Why?
- Christianity Does Not Explain Everything, Ross Douthat
- Ross Douthat Could Show You Proof You Should Be Christian, But He Doesn’t Want To
- Ross Douthat Admits He Loves Catholicism For Its Abusive Power
- Why Should We Let Ross Douthat’s Church Control Our Sex Lives?
- Fascism And Christianity Are Intertwined, Ross Douthat
- Following Magical Omens Is Not Rational, Ross Douthat
- The Flawed Logic In Ross Douthat’s Arguments For Christianity
- Truth Isn’t Proven In An Ideological Deathmatch, Ross Douthat
- The Work That Demons Do For Ross Douthat
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.