95 Studies: Repeating A Year Costs Two Months' Progress
From The Education Commute · 16:45
Show by The Education Commuter
It's the question that comes at the parents' evening door every time: would he do better if he just stayed down a year? The Education Endowment Foundation's Teaching and Learning Toolkit answers with a number instead of a feeling - and the number runs backwards, most steeply for exactly the child the question is usually asked about.What's covered: the EEF Teaching and Learning Toolkit's "Repeating a year" strand, updated October 2025, read live on the page. The toolkit's own definition: "Pupils who do not reach a given standard of learning join a class of younger students the following academic year." The headline figure: "about two months' less progress over the course of a year than if the same pupil had not repeated the year", worse in secondary than primary at "-4 months" against "-2 months", with effects that "tend to increase with time" and repeating more than one year "significantly increases the risk of students dropping out of school". The line called the most important sentence on the page: negative effects fall disproportionately on disadvantaged pupils, pupils from ethnic minorities, and pupils "relatively young in their year group". The possible mechanism offered, carefully: "pupils feeling stigmatised for failure and being in a class with younger pupils". The cost is rated very high. Three limits on the record: the evidence base of 95 studies is mainly American, evidence strength is rated low, and the toolkit offers no plan for an individual child beyond signposting one-to-one tuition as the alternative to consider.Sources: EEF, Teaching and Learning Toolkit - "Repeating a year", last updated October 2025. All free to open and linked in the show notes. Not covered: the admissions rules for summer-born children and the statutory processes around an education, health and care plan, which sit outside this strand. Both voices on this show are synthesised; the research, reading and editorial judgement are done by a serving practitioner.
More episodes of The Education Commute
More episodes
- Australia Removed 4.7 Million Accounts, 65.4% Said It Changed Nothing
- Ofsted In Secondary Schools
- Ofsted In Primary Schools
- Ofsted In Special Schools
- Inclusion: Strong To Exceptional
- Ofsted Inclusion, Explained Plainly
- Homework Without Doing It For Them: +5 Months, 43 EEF Studies
- PISA 2025: England Held Still As 25% Fell Below Level 2 In Maths
- Learning Styles: The EEF Found Zero Studies To Back Them
- 13 Behaviours, 9 Factors, No Single Profile: DfE's New Prevent Guidance
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.