AI and expert evidence, what law firms change now

From The Legal AI Brief · 16:09

Show by Saqib Khan, Adliora

On Friday 6 November 2026 Mrs Justice Joanna Smith, who co-chaired the Civil Justice Council working group on AI in court documents, told the Bond Solon Expert Witness Conference that experts should be ready now to disclose AI that has generated or influenced the substance of a report, to the court and to the solicitor who instructed them, without waiting for a rule change. She set out the three part test the council wants written into the guidance on instructing experts, the uses she doubted would need a declaration and how each can slide into substance, the strict protocol an expert needs where a team does the reading, and the ten questions to ask where AI has shaped the evidence. The Bond Solon and Law Society Gazette survey of 555 experts, published the same morning, found that over reliance on AI at the expense of professional judgement is the concern experts name most. Saqib Khan reads the speech for a firm of five to fifty people that instructs experts, from the letter of instruction that says nothing about AI and the security of the tool that client papers go into, to the questions to put to your own expert and to the other side’s. This week’s instruction is to add a paragraph to your next letter of instruction that says what AI use you permit and asks the expert to tell you, before they begin, what they intend to use. Also in this episode, the Lady Chief Justice’s annual report on litigants in person using AI, Dr Natalie Byrom’s report on sycophantic AI in the family courts, the government’s review of legal services regulation, and from the bench a thirty two page letter demanding that a deputy High Court judge reverse his draft judgment.

More episodes of The Legal AI Brief

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.