Episode 128: I talked my parents out of sending my sister to a boarding school upstate when I was nine and she has never once brought it up

From Creepy Encounters · 4:56

Show by Creepy Encounters

Submitted by Wes — Hicksville, New York. 41. When I was nine my sister Lacey almost went away to a boarding school in the Adirondacks, and I am the reason she didn't. I still have the brochure. It's glossy, soft at the corners, with a loon on the cover floating on a lake so flat it looks like a mirror, and the words "Where Every Student Is Known" across the top in green. I found it under her mattress the spring she was fourteen. I was looking for the Game Boy she'd confiscated. The brochure had pen marks all over it. She'd circled the part about single rooms for older students. She'd underlined "financial aid available" twice. On the back, where it listed the application deadline, she had written the date again in her own handwriting, like she was afraid it would move. I took it straight to my mom. I thought I was turning Lacey in. Instead my mom sat down on the edge of the tub and read the whole thing, and then she said, "Okay," quietly, and put it in her purse. For about three weeks after that, the brochure lived on our kitchen counter in Hicksville under the fruit bowl. My mom picked up extra shifts at the hospital. She called the school from the hallway with the cord stretched around the corner so we couldn't hear. My dad said, more than once, that we were not the kind of family that sends their kids away, and my mom said, more than once, that it wasn't sending her away, it was sending her somewhere. I didn't care about any of that. What I cared about was that Lacey was going to leave me alone in that house. She was the one who made me grilled cheese. She was the one who let me sit in her room while she did homework. That was also the year my dad's brother, Uncle Dale, moved into the finished basement after his divorce, right next to Lacey's room, until he got back on his feet. Lacey had been down there by herself for two years before that. She used to say the basement was the best room in the house. So one night at dinner I lost it. I cried until I couldn't breathe. I said if Lacey went, I would run away. I said she didn't love me. I said it in front of Uncle Dale, who laughed and rubbed my head and said, "Listen to this kid. Nobody's going anywhere." My dad said that settled it. My mom looked at Lacey across the table for a long time. Lacey didn't say anything. She just kept cutting her pork chop into smaller and smaller pieces. The brochure went in the junk drawer. I fished it out a week later and kept it in my own room, like a trophy. Lacey was different after that, but she was fourteen, and everybody told me fourteen-year-olds are like that. She joined every club her high school had. Drama, yearbook, the Key Club, things she had never cared about. She slept over at her friend Tamika's almost every weekend. She put a desk chair under her doorknob at night, which my dad said was ridiculous, and which she kept doing anyway. When I went down to sit with her while she did homework, she'd tell me to go back upstairs. Not mean. Just tired. Uncle Dale got back on his feet five years later, which was the same summer Lacey left for college in Oregon, which is about as far as you can get from Long Island without a passport. He drove her to the airport. He was always good about stuff like that. He drove her to her SATs, too, and to her prom pictures, because my dad worked Saturdays. Lacey lives in Portland now. She sends a Christmas card every year signed with just her name, nothing else, not "love," not the kids' names. When I turned thirty I mailed her the brochure as a joke, with a sticky note that said "Look what you almost missed out on." She never mentioned it. My mom told me later that Lacey called her that week and they talked for two hours, and when I asked about what, my mom said, "Old stuff," and changed the subject. Uncle Dale still comes to Thanksgiving. He still asks about her every year, first thing, befor…

More episodes of Creepy Encounters

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.