Weaponizing Winter? How a Hamas press release became a "deliberate murder" story, the Philly bike ride that backfired, and the NYT sued from both sides | With David Christopher Kaufman | Nov 12, 2026
From CHECKED by HonestReporting · 34:41
Show by HonestReporting
CHECKED is HonestReporting's weekly live show. Every Thursday, Ben Chertoff and Joe Truzman take apart the week's coverage of Israel. They look at what got reported, what got left out, and who decided.November 12, 2026:Front Page: It rained in Gaza last weekend. By the end of the storm, high-reach accounts were telling their audiences that Israel is weaponizing winter and deliberately killing babies. We trace how that story was built before the first raindrop fell: a November 1 press release from a Hamas government committee, repackaged four days later on Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor letterhead, then a Hamas Government Media Office claim of 70,000 flooded tents about 12 hours into the storm. Reuters, the BBC and NBC News carried the figure, not always attributed to Hamas. Then came the megaphone: UN special rapporteur Francesca Albanese reaching for Primo Levi, Ms. Rachel telling American parents the Israeli government is letting babies die, and Greta Thunberg. We look at what every link in the chain left out, including COGAT's public record of winter supplies entering Gaza and the Telegraph's report that Hamas security stopped Palestinian Authority workers from replacing flimsy tents with sturdier ones. Plus recycled and AI-generated flood footage, and how a sandbank collapse reached the Washington Post.The Feed: In Philadelphia, cyclists from five anti-Zionist groups rode through Rittenhouse Square past six Jewish-owned restaurants, calling for a boycott, on the eve of the anniversary of Kristallnacht. David Christopher Kaufman, HonestReporting contributor and founder of The Octagon Project, was there. He describes the crowds who lined up to buy from the targeted restaurants, the counter-protesters who met the riders at every stop, and how coverage shifted from calling it a "boycott" to calling it the boycott that didn't happen.Open Cases: One paper, two lawsuits. A reader is suing the New York Times for $50 million in emotional distress because it won't call Gaza a genocide without attributing the word. Shareholders, including Florida's state pension fund, are suing for internal records over Nicholas Kristof's column that ran a Hamas-linked allegation that IDF soldiers used dogs to sexually assault Palestinian prisoners. Being hit from both sides doesn't mean the Times is in the middle. It may mean its standards are being applied inconsistently.Honest Mistake, or On Purpose? Two cases, one ruling each. An IBTimes UK headline calling a UN expert's recycled dog-rape allegation a "bombshell," and an Independent paragraph that reduced October 7 to the Nova festival and credited a Gaza death toll to "humanitarian monitors." After we flagged it, the Independent corrected one of those errors and left the other one standing.Live every Thursday at 12:30 ET on YouTube, Instagram and X. Follow CHECKED on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Read David Christopher Kaufman's first-person report from Philadelphia at honestreporting.com.
More episodes of CHECKED by HonestReporting
More episodes
- Red, Blue, and Green: Midterm coverage, Tucker Carlson's nuclear tweet, and why RSF put HonestReporting on its predators list | With Justin Pozmanter | Nov 5, 2026
- Israel Votes! (And Steals Your Bananas): Election-week framing, Cenk Uygur's grocery-bill ad, and who really lit France's "student protests" | With Justin Pozmanter
- Extra Virgin Outrage: Lander's olive harvest, the Gaza aid story NPR half-told, and Palestine Action's new names | With Michael Starr
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.