#95: If God Is All-Good and All-Powerful, Why Is There So Much Suffering? | Peter van Inwagen
From Let’s Discuss · 00:48:37
Show by The Prometheans
Why would an all-powerful, all-good God permit a world filled with suffering?If God is perfectly good, why do innocent children suffer? Why do natural disasters destroy thousands of lives? Why do animals endure pain and death? And why does an apparently loving God remain silent in the face of so much suffering?In this episode of The Prometheans, I am joined by Professor Peter van Inwagen, one of the leading contemporary philosophers working in metaphysics, free will and philosophical theology, to examine one of the oldest and most formidable challenges to religious belief: the Problem of Evil.Drawing primarily on his influential book The Problem of Evil (2006), we explore his distinctive argument that the existence of suffering does not establish the non-existence of God. Van Inwagen deliberately distinguishes between a theodicy, which attempts to explain God's actual reasons for permitting suffering, and a defence, which offers an account that might be true for all we know.Our conversation examines:• Why van Inwagen believes the argument from evil fails, and what it means for a philosophical argument to fail.• The distinction between a defence and a theodicy.• His expanded free-will defence and the idea of humanity's separation from God.• Whether the evolutionary history of life and the suffering of animals pose a serious challenge to his account.• The no-minimum response: can God permit particular horrors if there is no minimum amount of suffering required for his purposes?• The range argument developed by John Martin Fischer and Neal Tognazzini: even if some suffering must exist, is the sheer amount of suffering in our world excessive?• The mystery of libertarian free will and its role in defending the existence of God.• Divine hiddenness: if God wishes to be known, why does he not make his existence unmistakable?And, finally, we confront a question that philosophical arguments cannot easily put aside: what can a defence of God's existence offer someone who has experienced unbearable suffering?ABOUT THE GUESTPeter van Inwagen is John Cardinal O'Hara Professor of Philosophy Emeritus at the University of Notre Dame. His influential contributions to contemporary philosophy include work on free will, metaphysics, personal identity and the philosophy of religion. He is particularly known for An Essay on Free Will (1983), Material Beings (1990), and The Problem of Evil (2006). He was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 2005 and served as President of the Society of Christian Philosophers from 2010 to 2013.This is not simply a debate about whether God exists. It is an examination of what philosophy can establish, what it cannot explain, and whether belief in a perfectly good God can remain intellectually defensible in a world of immense suffering.If you enjoy intellectually challenging conversations, consider subscribing to The Prometheans.If you enjoy The Prometheans and would like to support our work, you can buy us a coffee. Your support helps us continue researching, producing, and bringing scholars and thinkers to the channel. Thank you for helping us keep these conversations going. https://buymeacoffee.com/theprometheans
More episodes of Let’s Discuss
More episodes
- #94: Marxism and Liberalism: Can Freedom and Equality Coexist? | Matt McManus
- #93: Kafka’s The Trial: Are We Guilty Without Knowing Why? | Professor Espen Hammer
- #92: Can We Know Right from Wrong? | Walter Sinnott-Armstrong
- #91: Plato and Democracy: Did the Ancient Philosopher Predict the Death of Democracy? Angie Hobbs
- #90: Shakespeare’s Spiritual Secret: Did His Plays Reveal Something Beyond the Human? | Ewan Fernie
- #89: Does God’s Foreknowledge Destroy Human Freedom? | Katherin Rogers
- #88: Rethinking Existentialism: Freedom, Meaning, and the Search for Authenticity | Jonathan Webber
- #87: 500+ Theories of Mind, 9 Levels of Nothing: Robert Lawrence Kuhn on Reality's Last Mysteries
- #86: Viktor Frankl: Can Suffering Have Meaning? | Alexander Batthyány
- #85: What Is Madness? Psychiatry, Power & the Human Mind — Andrew Scull
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.