The Problem Is When Other People Let It Work: Dr. Carter J. Carter on Personality Disorders, Moral High Ground, and Why Leftist Institutions Implode
From The Poor Prole’s Almanac · 00:58:25
Show by The Poor Prole’s Alamanac, Bleav
Why do leftist institutions implode? Dr. Carter J. Carter has a theory, and it isn't flattering to anyone. She's a clinical social worker, psychoanalyst, professor and past president of Psychoanalysis for Social Responsibility, with more than twenty years of movement work behind her — and she has obsessive-compulsive personality disorder, which she manages with therapy and medication and writes about candidly. Personality disorders have been her clinical focus for her entire career. Her argument starts with a figure anyone who has sat through an organiser training will recognise: the "difficult person." When organisers write about why things fall apart, this is what they cite above everything else. Dr. Carter's contention is that the difficult person is usually, substantively, a person with a personality disorder — and that this cuts two ways at once. It means the traits that make them difficult are adaptations to an adverse life they never chose. And it means that if we're organising for the well-being of oppressed people, and oppression is traumatic, then people with these conditions aren't an inconvenience at the edge of our movements. They are a sizeable part of the constituency, and a sizeable part of the labour force. She includes herself in that. So the breakdown isn't caused by difficult individuals. It's caused by institutions that have no capacity to engage them — and since we know this is reliably where things break, that capacity should be a core organising competency. It isn't one. What would it take? Being able to tell someone the truth. We reach for the moral high ground, she argues, when we're frightened there's something shameful about us — an understandable impulse, not an evil one. "The problem isn't that people try to do that. The problem is when other people let it work." We also get into COINTELPRO, burnout as institutional amnesia, estrangement from parents, specialisation in Rojava and Chiapas, and why the implosion is a tendency rather than a destiny. Dr. Carter J. Carter writes at Psycho Analyst: carterjcarter.substack.com The essay we discuss: "Activism, Character, Disorder" Its companion piece: "Last Ditch Efforts" — the APA, the Last Ditch Bar, and the tangled fascist web Looking for a therapist? Dr. Carter's clinical practice: carterjcarter.com — clinical services · contact If any of this episode is live for you right now: in the US, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available by call or text. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
More episodes of The Poor Prole’s Almanac
More episodes
- Return of the Water Humans; Ben Goldfarb and the Beavers that Built America
- Oak Savanna Rising: Heather Holm on Native Pollinators and Fire-Dependent Landscapes
- The Last Man at Sunny Ridge Part 2: William Wiley and the World of J. Russell Smith
- The Poor Prole‘s Almanac Trailer
- Thriving in 2025: Climate Change, Complex Systems, and Sustainable Communities
- The Fundamentals of Resilient Soil
- Cultivating Resilience and Soil Health in Uncertain Times
- Some Thoughts on Homesteading and Prepping
- Beyond Deadwood: A Radical Approach to Forest Management
- Decoding Nature's Matrix: Unveiling the Secrets of Biomes
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.