If Anyone Can Make a Beautiful Image, Why Hire a Photographer?
From Who Gets Tomorrow · 00:08:49
Show by Who Gets Tomorrow
Europe's biggest online fashion shop closed its photo studios as it switched to AI images. So if anyone can make a beautiful picture, why would a company still hire a photographer?We follow the money behind a commercial photo: who still gets paid, and who quietly doesn't.A commercial shoot is a list of paid jobs: planning, photography, models, styling, lighting, studio space and retouching. AI can cut much of that list even when a photographer keeps a smaller job.We hear from working photographers on both sides: Jack Davison and Xiaopeng Zhan on what clients now ask for, and Fynn Badgley and Chris Howlett on where AI still falls short.Our analysis: the accounts suggest the market is dividing by volume, not by beauty. Fast, high-volume catalog work and its crews face real pressure, while careful high-end shoots change more slowly. These are chosen stories, not a survey, and no source gives a reliable total of jobs lost.Chapters0:00 The studio that closed0:53 Why hire a photographer?1:18 The fear, stated fairly2:00 Losses beyond the camera2:37 One photo, many paid jobs3:29 What clients ask for now4:16 The strongest counter5:14 Volume, not beauty6:04 More pictures, less pay?6:33 Who wins, who pays7:35 Our forecast8:20 Your turnOur forecast: in the first comparable Association of Photographers survey published in 2027, at least half of responding members will again report losing paid work to AI. Confidence: likely (about 65%). Wrong if below half; unresolved if no comparable survey appears in 2027.SourcesEvidence:- UK professional photography trade association: AOP Copyright & AI Member Survey Results, January 2026 https://www.the-aop.org/uploads/aop-member-survey-copyright-ai-january-2026.pdf- Reuters: Fashion's AI era: face swaps and digital clones https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/fashions-ai-era-face-swaps-digital-clones-2026-10-27/Signals (individual accounts, unverified unless stated):- Unverified self-described commercial photographers and assistants: Public Reddit commercial-worker accounts: product photographers and photo assistants https://www.reddit.com/r/productphotography/comments/1tmpukb/product_photographer_replaced/- Wonderful Machine; photography production and consulting business: 2026 State of the Photo Industry Survey https://wonderfulmachine.com/article/state-of-the-photo-industry-2026/- Self (writer and e-commerce stylist): AI stole my styling job https://1granary.substack.com/p/ai-stole-my-styling-job- TalkPhotography forum (UK): High skill/high quality photography being rejected as AI? https://www.talkphotography.co.uk/posts/9742333/Insider views:- PHLEARN; Photoshop Training Channel; PhotoshopCAFE: The Future of Photo Editing: The State of the Industry in 2026 https://phlearn.com/magazine/future-of-photo-editing/- Independent commercial food/product photographer; own business website: Real Food Product Photography Beats AI: Why Leading Brands Still Choose the Camera https://www.howlettphoto.com/blog/real-food-product-photography-beats-ai- Thomsen Photography; Profoto ambassador; AI-Mindset educator: How photographer Ines Thomsen lights up AI images with Profoto https://www.profoto.com/ee/en/still-photography/profoto-stories/how-photographer-ines-thomsen-lights-up-ai-images-with-profoto/BlogPage- Commercial photographer/creative director; Yummy Production, as identified in article biography: A Commercial Photographer's Take on When to Use AI (and When Not To) https://petapixel.com/2026/05/10/a-commercial-photographers-take-on-when-to-use-ai-and-when-not-to/- PetaPixel: Photographers Raise Concerns as AI Use Surges Among Clients https://petapixel.com/2026/04/22/photographers-raise-concerns-as-ai-use-surges-among-clients/- Fstoppers contributor; commercial fashion photographer: Has AI Ended My Fashion Photography Career? https://fstoppers.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-ended-my-fashion-photography-career-901334Company claims:- Fashion retailer; first-party marketing announcement: H&M continues its exploration of creativity with AI https://hmgroup.com/news/hm-continues-its-exploration-of-creativity-with-ai/Made with AI: the narration voice is synthetic and the illustrations are AI-generated and clearly illustrative, not photographs of real people or events. AI tools assist production; research and editorial decisions are human-reviewed.Corrections: if new evidence changes our verdict, we log it and follow up.Watch the video: https://youtu.be/NHCJTHm4VpA
More episodes of Who Gets Tomorrow
More episodes
- If America Slows AI, Does China Win?
- If AI Does All the Work, Who Pays You?
- Your Bank Just Banned Your AI. Should It Have?
- An AI Said No Tools. Then It Tried to Reach Beijing
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.