Who Was Ordered to Pay the Isley Brothers' Song $5.4 Million?
From Music & Royalties Explained · 14:27
Show by The Griot
The Isley Brothers' 1966 recording of Love Is a Wonderful Thing never cracked the Hot One Hundred. Michael Bolton's 1991 song of the same name led off a number-one, eight-times-platinum album. A jury found infringement, and the judgment - affirmed all the way to the Supreme Court's door - came to five point four million dollars, with Sony Music owing four point two million of it.The episode follows the whole record: the access case built from radio testimony, a benefit-concert remark and a studio work tape in which Bolton asks whether the tune is Marvin Gaye's; the five shared musical elements the musicologist identified, none protectable alone, the combination the jury found unique; the jury's 28 percent of the album's profits and 66 percent of the song's; and the tax rulings that let Bolton and Goldmark deduct taxes actually paid while refusing Sony's paper offset. The Supreme Court declined review in January 2001, and the award stood.
More episodes of Music & Royalties Explained
More episodes
- What Are the Four Kinds of Music Royalty? A Map in Plain English
- Why Did PRS Freeze Shape of You Royalties? The Oh Why Case, Start to Finish
- What Does a Songwriter's Royalty Share Sell For? The 2018 K.K. Downing Catalog Sale
- Work for Hire or Assignment? The Ghostwriter Who Signed for Five Hundred Dollars
- Did 2 Live Crew Owe Roy Orbison's Publisher for Pretty Woman? The Supreme Court Said No
- What Does It Cost to Legally Release a Cover Song? The 2026 Mechanical License Math
- Who Owed Whom After Come Together? Lennon, Levy and the Roots Album
- How Much Does Spotify Pay in 2026? The Loud & Clear Numbers, Rung by Rung
- Did a Two-Second Guitar Sample Need a License? The Sixth Circuit Said Yes
- Where Can a Songwriter Sue for Thirty Thousand Dollars Without a Big Legal Bill? Inside the Copyright Claims Board
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.