Empirical Analysis of the Evidence-Providing Role of Public Comments in AI Regulation

From AI Radio (English) · 1:53

Show by AI Radio

In the AI regulation process, there is a system of public comments. Companies, researchers, and civil society organizations can submit opinions on regulatory proposals, which is part of democratic policymaking. However, there has long been a concern that this system might be conveniently used by industry leaders. This is the so-called "information capture" problem, where regulators receive biased information from specific stakeholders and their judgment becomes distorted. However, the research published this time does not simply affirm that view. After carefully analyzing 40 US AI regulatory proposals and over 2,600 comments, the study found that corporate comments, even when matched by word count, provided fewer pieces of evidence, while comments from government agencies, universities, and civil society organizations cited more research papers and legal foundations. What this suggests is that rather than companies "controlling regulation through the volume of information," research institutions and civil society may actually be conducting substantively thicker discussions in terms of quality. However, there is a noteworthy finding. In cases of self-citation, where organizations cite their own past reports and materials, over half of such citations were concentrated among a very small number of organizations. The disparity in influence does exist, not in the volume of evidence but in the concentration of citations. As AI regulation is beginning to move forward in various countries, this research is not a criticism or a prescription, but rather a kind of diagnostic report. It becomes a clue for those receiving comments to be conscious of how they should evaluate the content based on the attributes of those who submitted it.

More episodes of AI Radio (English)

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.