What I Got Wrong About Remote Work
From Uphoff on Media Podcast · 14:36
Show by Tony Uphoff
In March 2021 I wrote that “all knowledge work will inevitably be done in remote first and office second environments.” Then, with some confidence, I added: “Frankly we’re already there.”Five years later I owe you a scorecard. I got productivity right, and recruiting right, for a while. I got half of remote first right. And I was wrong about who would push back.The bigger miss wasn’t on the scorecard at all. The fight over how many days people spend in the office was the wrong fight. Remote work didn’t break feedback. It broke the two things you can’t put on a calendar: learning by example, and reading the room.If you’re building or running a B2B information, marketing or technology company, this is your problem more than almost anyone’s. Nearly half the people in the information industry still work from home at least part of the time, and the cost of getting this wrong won’t show up for years.Here is how my 2021 calls held upRemote first, office second: partially right. About 26% of paid workdays in the US are now worked from home, up from 7% in 2019. Remote work stuck. But the model that won was office some days, not remote first.Productivity holds or improves: right. ThomasNet went fully remote in March 2020 and never went back full time. I watched productivity, attention to detail and discretionary effort go up, not down. Stanford’s Nick Bloom points to a surge in US productivity growth that started exactly when working from home ramped up.Remote opens a recruiting advantage: right, for about two years. When everyone could hire from anywhere, nobody had an edge. Then the big employers pulled back, and fully remote roles shrank to a small slice of new postings. The advantage didn’t disappear. It moved to whoever still offers remote.The push to go back comes from commercial real estate and culture pessimists: wrong. I wrote that most of those arguments were “being made by people actively involved in commercial real estate, or people predicting a dire impact on company cultures.” Then Amazon, Dell and a long list of software companies mandated a return. None of them sell office space.The pendulum stopped at Tuesday through ThursdayPolicy moved. Behavior barely did. Between early 2024 and mid-2025, the number of office days companies require rose 12%, while actual attendance rose only 1% to 3%. This September, even Tuesday, the busiest day of the week, was at only 65% of its early-2020 level. Most companies settled on a schedule. Their people settled on the middle of the week.Remote was a forcing function, and it exposed who was managing by just walking aroundThe shift to remote forced companies to build structured, scheduled communication: one-on-ones on video, more Slack, work tracked in Monday or Trello. Companies that built those loops held up. In the ones that didn’t, people felt they were getting less feedback, because the quick aside at the coffee machine or on an elevator ride had always felt like feedback.It also tested leaders in a way none of us had been tested. Plenty of managers had been running on presence and personality rather than systems, process and knowledge. Remote took the presence away, and it showed. As I argued in Goals Are for Losers. Systems Are for Winners., the test of a system is whether anything happens when the numbers go wrong. Walking the floor isn’t a system.What I didn’t predict was how well people adapted inside their teams. What weakened were the bridges between them. When Microsoft studied 61,182 of its US employees, remote work cut the share of collaboration time spent across groups by about 25%. One-on-ones on a good cadence fix the feedback gap. They do nothing for the bridges.Learning by example doesn’t fit on a calendarAs a young sales rep at EE Times, I learned how to plan my work and work my plan, how to manage a schedule, how to make a cold call, how to handle customers, colleagues and bosses, and how to conduct myself at a company function. Nobody taught me most of it. I was close enough to see how people who knew far more than I did actually worked, and I would never have moved into management as fast without that.That’s the thing I missed in 2021. I was thinking about experienced people doing work they already knew how to do. I wasn’t picturing the 24-year-old trying to learn the job from a grid of video tiles.The data has caught up. New York Fed researchers estimate that remote work explains 64% of the rise in unemployment among young college graduates. Inside one Fortune 500 tech company, feedback fell after the move to remote, and the drop hit junior engineers hardest. The company shifted to hiring people about a decade older, and only went back to hiring new graduates after an aggressive return-to-office policy.Remote by default starves the people with the most to learn. The cost doesn’t show up this quarter. It shows up around 2030, as a bench of managers you never developed.You can’t read a room on ZoomIn 2006, in my first month at UBM as the new…
More episodes of Uphoff on Media Podcast
More episodes
- The Crossover Point
- The Forecast Has Your Name on It
- Everyone in B2B Data Is Selling Context Now. Rebrand or Reposition?
- The Three Decisions a Machine Can’t Make for You
- Production is Getting Cheaper. Judgement Isn’t
- It's Never Just Business
- Your Team Got More Productive. Did Your Business?
- I Asked AI Who to Hire. It Recommended Me. Once
- Enterprise Software is at a Crossroads
- You’re Running the Wrong Business Model. And Agentic AI Will Prove It.
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.