Dr. Lily Kurtz | Who Is Your Athlete Without Their Sport?
From Be Valiant | The Podcast for Sports Parents · 01:03:02
Show by Valiant Sports Society
Who is your child beyond the jersey, the team, the wins, and the accomplishments? For many young athletes, sports become more than something they do. Sports become who they are. Their friendships, confidence, sense of belonging, and even self-worth can become deeply connected to their athletic identity. But what happens when an injury, a difficult coach, lost playing time, or the end of their competitive journey threatens that identity? And how can sports parents recognize the warning signs before their child's mental health is affected? In this episode of Be Valiant, host Todd Merkow welcomes Dr. Lily Kurtz, a board-certified psychiatric nurse practitioner, former collegiate swimmer at Tufts University, athlete mental health researcher, and advisor to Valiant Sports Society. Together, they explore how athletic identity develops, the risks of identity foreclosure, and why young athletes need opportunities to discover who they are beyond their sport. Dr. Kurtz also shares her personal experience with Division I recruiting pressure, the abrupt ending of her collegiate swimming career during COVID, and how those experiences helped shape her work supporting the mental health of current and former athletes. IN THIS EPISODE Athletic Identity: How young athletes develop their sense of self and when a strong athletic identity can become unhealthy. Identity Foreclosure: What happens when an athlete commits to a single identity without exploring other interests, relationships, and experiences. The Pressure to Perform: How recruiting expectations, competition, and the pursuit of Division I opportunities can influence self-worth. Coaches, Parents & Team Culture: How the sports environment can strengthen or undermine an athlete's confidence and sense of belonging. Injury, Setbacks & Identity Loss: Why losing playing time, changing teams, or experiencing an injury can disrupt an athlete's sense of self. Life After Sports: How parents can help prepare their children for the emotional challenges of transitioning away from competitive athletics. Protecting Mental Health: Warning signs parents should recognize and when professional support may be needed. THE VALIANT PARENT PLAYBOOK Imagine a 14-year-old athlete whose confidence and happiness have become tied to their performance. A bad game can affect them for days. What should their parents recognize, and what should they do? Dr. Kurtz encourages parents to look beyond athletic achievement, reinforce their child's qualities and relationships outside sports, and help them understand that their value is not determined by their performance. The takeaway: Help your child build a sense of identity and belonging that exists whether they win, lose, play, or walk away from their sport. EXPLORE MORE AT PLAYFEARLESS.ORG Understanding athletic identity is an important part of protecting young athletes' emotional well-being. Explore free educational resources, expert conversations, and practical guidance designed to help sports parents make more informed decisions. Mental Health Education: https://playfearless.org/learn/mental-health Valiant Sports Society: https://playfearless.org EPISODE CHAPTERS 00:00 – Welcome to Be Valiant 03:24 – Lily's Youth Sports Journey and Collegiate Swimming 07:11 – Division I Pressure, Recruiting, and Self-Worth 16:14 – An Abrupt Ending and a Career in Athlete Mental Health 21:35 – Understanding Athletic Identity and Identity Foreclosure 32:10 – Injuries, Coaches, and Disruptions to Athletic Identity 40:00 – The Role of Parents, Coaches, and Sports Environments 48:00 – Athletic Retirement, Identity Loss, and Mental Health 53:49 – The Valiant Parent Playbook 56:25 – Rapid Fire and What It Means to Be Valiant ABOUT BE VALIANT Hosted by Todd Merkow, Founder and CEO of Valiant Sports Society, Be Valiant features conversations with athletes, parents, coaches, clinicians, and experts to help families navigate the emotional and physical challenges of youth sports. Valiant Sports Society is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization providing free multimedia education and resources that empower sports parents to make more informed decisions for their young athletes. More Happy Moments. Less Harmful Ones.™ https://playfearless.org DISCLAIMER This episode is intended for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare or mental health professional regarding individual concerns. © 2026 Valiant Sports Society. All rights reserved.
More episodes of Be Valiant | The Podcast for Sports Parents
More episodes
- Leeann Passaro | What Happens When You Let Your Athlete Lead?
- Bobbi Moran | Are We Losing Sight of What Matters in High School Sports?
- Dr. Matt Kritz | Is Your Young Athlete Really Ready? The Missing Piece in Youth Sports
- Dr. Tiana Woolridge | Are We Pushing Young Athletes Too Hard?
- Part 2: Brigitte Shulze | A Power for Good: The Legacy of Sarah Shulze
- Part 1: Brigitte Shulze | Who Was Sarah Shulze? A Mother Shares the Life Behind the Athlete
- Callista Elmore | Love the Game. Protect the Kid. | NCAA Softball Champion and Sports Parent
- David Murray | Author · Soccer Dad | Chasing the Dream Without Losing the Joy
- Brea Schmidt, The Top Bleacher | This Is About the Kids: Becoming the Sports Parent They Need
- Why Be Valiant? The Parent's Journey Through Youth Sports - Monologue by Todd Merkow (Host of Be Valiant and founder of Valiant Sports Society)
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.