#70 - Is Robotic Knee Replacement Really Better? Sam MacDessi, MD
From The Joint Replacement Podcast · 01:02:38
Show by Matthew Sloan, MD
Is robotic knee replacement really better? And have surgeons been aligning knee replacements incorrectly for decades?In Episode #70, Dr. Matthew Sloan interviews Professor Sam MacDessi, MD, an internationally recognized Australian knee surgeon, developer of the CPAK classification, and leader of the landmark RASKAL randomized trial.The RASKAL study compared robotic-assisted versus computer-navigated knee replacement and functional versus mechanical alignment.The findings challenge some common assumptions:• No significant differences in patient-reported outcomes at two years.• Robotic surgery was approximately 11 minutes faster and better preserved the posterior cruciate ligament.• Personalized functional alignment reduced the need for ligament releases from 44% to 8%.• Despite initially being skeptical of robotics, Dr. MacDessi now routinely uses robotic technology in his own practice.Together, we explore why every knee shouldn't necessarily be made perfectly straight, what CPAK tells us about natural knee anatomy, how surgeons determine whether a knee is balanced, and why precise technology hasn't yet consistently demonstrated better patient-reported outcomes.We also discuss cementless knee replacement in older patients, personalized tibial slope, kneecap tracking, implant longevity, and whether robotic surgery will eventually replace conventional instruments.The central question: Are robotic surgeons getting better at performing knee replacement before we've figured out exactly what the ideal knee replacement should be?Subscribe to The Joint Replacement Podcast for expert conversations on hip and knee replacement surgery.Get my free weekly newsletter, Strong Joints, Strong Body:https://matthews-newsletter-05056c.beehiiv.com/subscribeLearn more: www.matthewsloandmd.comFor educational purposes only. Not individualized medical advice.
More episodes of The Joint Replacement Podcast
More episodes
- #69 - Which Hip Replacement Approach Is Best? Anterior, Posterior, Lateral, Superior
- #68 - Is Robotic Joint Replacement Really Better? Kevin Lawson, MD
- #67 - Is My Hip or Knee Replacement Failing? 7 Warning Signs vs. Normal Healing
- #66 - When Is It Time for Hip or Knee Replacement? Craig Della Valle, MD
- #65 - When Does a Hip Replacement Feel Normal Again?
- #64 - Can We END Knee Replacements by 2043? Marc Pietropaoli, MD
- #63 - Why Can't I Sleep After Hip or Knee Replacement? 7 Tips From a Surgeon
- #62 - Is Anterior Hip Replacement Really Better? Charles Lawrie, MD
- #60 - What Should You Eat Before Joint Replacement Surgery? Sagar Desai, MD
- #61 - What Do Celebrities Know About Joint Replacement That You Don't? Jason Snibbe, MD
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.