Did Romantasy Kill Historical Romance? with Leslie Schicht, Owner of Poor Charlotte's Books
From Your Mom's Romance Shelf · 00:52:37
Show by Alli Mowrey
Did romantasy kill historical romance? Romance bookstore owner Leslie Schicht opened Poor Charlotte’s, the Cincinnati area’s only romance bookstore, after asking one question: what if the saddest spinster in literature had a romance shelf? The store is named after Charlotte Bartlett from A Room with a View, and just celebrated its first birthday in Covington, Kentucky.Wherever you’re listening from, this one’s for historical romance lovers. We talk about whether romantasy stole historical readers, why the stakes in older romance feel so much higher, how to love the “amazing and highly problematic” bodice rippers, where to go after Bridgerton, and why Leslie mentally adds ten years to every seventeen-year-old heroine.Chapters00:00 Cold open00:54 Intro02:01 Where the name Poor Charlotte’s comes from04:13 Why open a romance-only bookstore11:48 What we’re reading now18:16 Are readers buying historical romance?20:19 Did romantasy steal historical readers?22:03 Bring back the bodice ripper24:25 Why historical stakes feel higher28:40 Contemporary authors who raise the stakes32:08 The Bridgerton effect34:41 What to read after Bridgerton36:17 Must-read historical romance authors38:15 Whitney, My Love, The Flame and the Flower and problematic favorites44:38 Why are historical heroines so young?46:37 Lightning round recommendations49:41 What romance readers look like on a SaturdayVisit Poor Charlotte’s112 W. Pike St., Covington, KY. Open Wednesday through SundayShop online: poorcharlottes.comInstagram: @poorcharlottesFacebook: Poor Charlotte’s BooksBooks mentionedEvery book we talked about is listed at allireadstoomuch.com/podcast. A few highlights:Nostalgic and historical romanceParadise, Almost Heaven and Whitney, My Love by Judith McNaughtThe Flame and the Flower by Kathleen E. WoodiwissThe Secret by Julie GarwoodThe Bridgerton series by Julia QuinnThe Slightly series by Mary BaloghThe Bareknuckle Bastards series by Sarah MacLeanThe Legend of the Four Soldiers series by Elizabeth HoytTo Woo and Wed by Martha WatersCat Sebastian and KJ Charles for queer historicalsCurrent readsGrim Tidings by B.K. BorisonInto the Blue by Emma BrodieLet’s Be Real by Julia WolfTropesick by Lauren OkieHow to End a Love Story by Yulin KuangConnect with AlliInstagram: @allireadstoomuchTikTok: @allireadstoomuchYouTube: @allireadstoomuchFacebook: allireadstoomuchSubstack: @allireadstoomuch
More episodes of Your Mom's Romance Shelf
More episodes
- Before BookTok, There Were Book Bloggers: Shauna Casey on Indie Romance, AI & Human Connection
- Susan Elizabeth Phillips on Sports Romance, Alpha Heroes, Epic Grovels & the Evolution of Romance
- Romance, Sexism & the Books That Shaped the Genre with Jodi McAlister
- Introducing Your Mom’s Romance Shelf: A Nostalgic Romance Book Podcast
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.