Why do so few school improvement initiatives actually improve outcomes?

From Making Change Stick: The Art and Science of School Improvement · 00:27:05

Show by Dr James Mannion

What proportion of school improvement initiatives actually improve outcomes for pupils? Have a think and come up with a percentage before you press play.In this fourth episode of Making Change Stick: The Art and Science of School Improvement, Dr James Mannion shares the question he’s put to thousands of teachers and school leaders around the world. The answer usually comes back at 10-20%. When you tighten the criteria, most people revise their figure down to single figures. The tighter version asks for data showing the improvement, some sense of causation, and gains sustained over several years.Is this just anecdotal? James looks at three clues, and they all point in the same direction:Experts in change management. John Kotter estimates that more than 70% of needed change never gets launched, never gets finished, or comes in late and over budget with its aims unmet.The research evidence. The Education Endowment Foundation has evaluated 256 ‘high-potential’ projects in randomised controlled trials, and 79 of them had a positive impact on learning outcomes. That’s a success rate of around 30%. In the US, the Gates Foundation spent around $2 billion breaking large schools into smaller ones, with results Bill Gates described as ‘disappointing’.Teacher surveys. When Teacher Tapp put the question to around 10,000 teachers, 71% put the success rate below 30%.So why is the success rate so low? James focuses on two reasons we can do something about:Teachers and school leaders aren’t taught how to implement change. Leadership training touches on a few change models. The EEF’s implementation guidance is a high-level framework and is light on the practical detail schools need.We default to top-down change. It works well for simple problems with a clear cause and effect, such as litter in the corridors. With complex problems, it backfires in six ways: black box leadership, human nature, hollow consultation exercises, an ‘us and them’ culture, a compliance mindset and groupthink.The way forward? Slice teams: a cross-section of your school community, working together to plan and lead change. They work with the grain of human nature, give people a voice and a choice, and are the best antidote to groupthink there is.Next time, James explores the science behind it all: implementation science and improvement science.Chapters00:00 The mind-blowing question00:56 Tightening the criteria02:17 Clue 1: experts in change management05:41 Clue 2: the research evidence07:14 Clue 3: teacher surveys08:09 4 billion hours a year10:29 Why is the success rate so low?13:00 Reason 1: we're not taught how to implement change17:07 Reason 2: top-down change19:15 Six ways top-down change backfires24:12 Slice teamsYour challenge: Ask the mind-blowing question at your next staff or leadership meeting. What figure do your colleagues come up with? What happens when you tighten the criteria?Free download: the first two chapters of Making Change StickRead Chapters A and B of the book for free. They cover everything in this episode in more depth, with full references: https://www.makingchangestick.co/chapters-a-bNewsletterSign up for the newsletter to receive updates, new episodes and free resources: https://www.rethinkingjames.com/newslettersGet in touchWhat’s your answer to the mind-blowing question? James would love to hear it, and may share some listener responses in a future episode: https://www.makingchangestick.co/contactReferencesKotter, J. (2008). A Sense of Urgency. Harvard Business Press.Bryk, A. S., Gomez, L. M., Grunow, A. & LeMahieu, P. G. (2015). Learning to Improve: How America’s Schools Can Get Better at Getting Better. Harvard Education Press.Education Endowment Foundation, projects and evaluations: educationendowmentfoundation.org.ukGates, B. (2008). Forum on Education in America: prepared remarks.Teacher Tapp survey, January 2024.Janis, I. (1971). Groupthink. Psychology Today, 5(6), 43–6.

More episodes of Making Change Stick: The Art and Science of School Improvement

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.