Episode 5: Ifeoma Ozoma wants schools to serve students, not vendors.

From Home Screen Podcast · 1:00:40

Show by Emily Tavoulareas

I recently had the pleasure of speaking with Ifeoma Ozoma, who has spent her career on both sides of Big Tech. We spent more than an hour talking about tech in schools, and probably could have talked for five more.She has worked at Google, Facebook, and Pinterest, and has seen up close how these companies make decisions and what drives them. She also knows a thing or two about pushing back on Big Tech, from her experience as a whistleblower, to co-sponsoring California’s Silenced No More Act, to her current efforts to push back on tech in New Mexico classrooms.In 2022 she was named to the TIME100 Next list and the BBC’s 100 Women. Today she is Director of Technology Policy for Kapor Center Advocacy, where she works on tech industry accountability and public policy. But for the purposes of our conversation, she is the mom of a three-year-old living in New Mexico, where she organized the campaign against Amira, an AI reading assessment the state required for kids in kindergarten through second grade.Not only is Ifeoma incredibly clear-eyed about how tech companies and their products work, she is also especially focused on how procurement and contracts factor into decisions. When she told me that her focus is “almost obsessively on procurement,” and on the use and misuse of public funds, I knew I was in for a treat.Ifeoma’s focus on the financial and legal side of the equation makes her perspective especially useful right now, because she understands where the problem is rooted: in the web of contracts that reveals how technical systems, operational needs, classroom workflows, and financial commitments are all entangled.The has led her to ask:“Is our public education department a public education department, or an arm of a vendor?”We spent a good deal of time talking about Google’s recent announcement that opting out of AI means opting out of Google Search. And while my instinct had been, “OK, let’s change the default search engine,” it turns out it’s not quite so simple. Because (ready?) while it’s technically possible, safety features and blockers often come from a third party, which means yet another contractor… of course.Her advice for parents who want to push back on tech in their kids’ schools was simple:* File public records requests. Find out how much money your school is spending on a product, and whose name is on the contract. How to do this varies by state, but you can literally just start by searching “how do I file a public records request in [state]?”* Think beyond your own kid. Kids who can read and think critically become the adults who drive next to us, work in our hospitals, and vote. That makes this everyone’s business.As always, I’ve pulled the highlights from our conversation below. You can listen to the full episode above (or wherever you get your podcasts), watch it on YouTube, and find short clips on Instagram.💡“Aha” moments* There is a tension between “individualized learning” and claims of of standardization and scale. These things are in conflict. * Google knows exactly how much schools depend on it. Ifeoma suspects Google has has tons of data on how heavily its products are used in schools — data that schools haven’t shared with the public. This may be what gave Google the confidence to issue its ultimatum. It was betting schools wouldn’t walk away, because they know that at this point, “school is Google.”* If schools are saying they cannot teach without Google, they’ve become vendor deployers instead of educators. * Even what seems like a simple action — like changing the default search engine — is not quite as simple as it seems, because it requires untangling a whole web of contracts. * Individuals have more choice than schools do. You can cancel a subscription any month you want, but large school systems get locked into contracts that rarely change.✨Highlights“I feel very strongly that the point, especially for pre-K and early elementary, is for her to be interacting directly with her classmates and with her teachers. And so for me, it was really important that she started out school in a space where there is no interruption of those very important social interactions by a screen.”— Ifeoma Ozoma“... and so my interest in screens and in contracts in our public education system, with ed tech companies and with vendors, has been: do we even have evidence of efficacy and do we have evidence of of a proper use of these funds? And that that has been my one track focus. That yes, there’s so many developmental concerns, absolutely those are important, but fundamentally we’re talking about using public funds for contracts where we don’t have evidence that it’s actually improving outcomes for our kids.”— Ifeoma Ozoma“Is our public education department a public education department or an arm of a vendor? Because it’s very unclear to me when you’re looking at situations like Amira in our state and many other vendors, whether the state or the school or the district is setting the agenda…

More episodes of Home Screen Podcast

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.