How to Prepare Performance Reviews as a Manager (Even If It's Your First Time)

From From a Woman to a Leader · 00:16:43

Show by Limor Bergman Gross

More than once as a director, I walked into a calibration meeting sure about my team's ratings, and walked out having to change them. Not because my people weren't good, but because I hadn't prepared the right way.Last week I talked about preparing for your own review and asking for the impact, not the title. This week I'm flipping the chair. If you're a manager running performance reviews for your team, especially for the first time, this episode walks you through how to prepare: whether your company has a polished process or just a blank doc and a deadline.In this episode:A step-by-step review process you can use even if your company doesn't have oneThe self-review questions to give your teamHow to gather evidence from the whole year, not just the last two monthsHow rating scales work in tech (3, 4 and 5 point) and how ratings are usually distributedThe real difference between Meeting and Exceeding expectationsThe two traps first-time managers fall into when rating their teamWhy career development is a partnership, not something you hand your peopleYour homework: pick one person on your team and write one sentence describing what "Exceeding" would look like for them at their level.Next week: the review conversation itself. How to open it, handle disagreement, and deliver "Meeting" to someone who expected more.Missed last week's episode? Listen to "How to Prepare for Your Performance Review as an Engineering Manager": https://limorbergman.com/episodes/how-to-prepare-for-your-performance-review-ask-for-impact-not-a-title/Navigating your first review cycle as a manager and want support? Book a call: https://limorbergman.com/coaching/Chapters:(00:00) Why I had to change my team's ratings(00:39) How to prepare reviews as a manager(01:42) Step 1: Set the timeline(02:22) Step 2: Self-review questions(04:44) Step 3: Gather evidence(05:57) Watch out for recency bias(07:04) Step 4: Sanity-check your ratings(07:41) Step 5: Find the gaps(08:24) Rating scales and distributions(09:55) Meeting expectations is not failing(10:28) Meeting vs Exceeding(12:39) Two traps first-time managers fall into(13:13) Rate against level expectations(14:09) Bring evidence, don't share early(15:01) Career development is a partnership(15:35) Your homework this weekConnect with Limor:Website: https://limorbergman.comPodcast: https://limorbergman.com/podcast/LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/limorbergman/Substack: https://limorbergman.substack.comKeywords: performance reviews, how to write performance reviews, new manager, first-time manager, engineering manager, calibration, rating scale, meeting vs exceeding expectations, self-review questions, women in tech, leadership

More episodes of From a Woman to a Leader

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.