Case Explained: CASTILLO HURTADO, ET AL. V. BLANCHE
From DIFTCL: Federal Narrative Summaries · 1:49
Show by Do It For The Caselaw
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit Filed: 2026-11-20 The Ninth Circuit denied the petition for review filed by Richard Castillo Hurtado and his family seeking asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). The court affirmed the Board of Immigration Appeals’ (BIA) decision to deny these forms of relief. Regarding asylum and withholding of removal, the court applied the substantial evidence standard, holding that the BIA correctly found the petitioners were targeted exclusively for financial gain rather than on account of a protected ground such as political opinion or membership in a particular social group. The court noted that under 8 U.S.C. § 1158(b)(1)(B)(i) and § 1231(b)(3)(A), a protected ground must be at least one central reason for the persecution, and the record contained substantial evidence, including the lead petitioner’s testimony, that the criminal groups targeted the family for money. The court also affirmed the BIA’s refusal to consider new particular social group claims raised for the first time on appeal. Regarding CAT protection, the court found substantial evidence supported the agency’s determination that the petitioners failed to establish a clear probability of torture with government acquiescence. The court clarified that while willful blindness may constitute acquiescence, a government does not acquiesce merely because it is aware of but powerless to stop torture. The record showed Peruvian law enforcement took the petitioners’ reports seriously and conducted investigations, even if fruitless, negating the claim of acquiescence. Finally, the court rejected the petitioners’ ineffective assistance of counsel claim, ruling that they failed to comply with *Lozada* requirements and could not demonstrate prejudice. The court reasoned that even if prior counsel had been effective in presenting a protected ground, the relief would have been denied anyway because the evidence showed the persecution was motivated solely by financial reasons. As a practical consequence, the petition is denied, and the temporary stay of removal entered pursuant to General Order 6.4(c) is lifted immediately, allowing for the enforcement of the removal order. Do It For The Case Law is a news reporting service. Nothing in this episode constitutes legal advice.
More episodes of DIFTCL: Federal Narrative Summaries
More episodes
- Case Explained: BENSON V. MYERS, ET AL.
- Case Explained: United States of America Plaintiff— v. Olabode Thomas Ajibola Defendant—Appellant consolidated with
- Case Explained: JUANA ELIZALDE CASTILLO v. TODD W. BLANCHE, Attorney General of the United States
- Case Explained: SEAN PAUL REYES v. RICHARD VOLANTI
- Case Explained: Peter Reeves Plaintiff— v. Sam Dobbins
- Case Explained: SARITA ESTEFANIA HUAMAN-HERNANDEZ v. ATTORNEY GENERAL UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
- Case Explained: State of Texas Plaintiff— v. Todd Wallace Blanche, U.S. Attorney General
- Case Explained: AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC v. NEO WIRELESS LLC
- Case Explained: A. M. A. S. V. MULLIN, ET AL.
- Case Explained: BROWN V. ADAMSON, ET AL.
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.