Ty Cobb, Part Two: The Man Who Invented Him
From Baseball Hall of Fame Lives · 17:58
Show by MT
EPISODE TITLE Ty Cobb, Part Two: The Man Who Invented HimSHORT DESCRIPTION A forged diary sat in the Hall of Fame for eleven years. The man who wrote it also invented most of what you know about Ty Cobb.SHOW NOTES In 2009, after an FBI investigation, a Ty Cobb diary that Major League Baseball had bought and donated to the National Baseball Hall of Fame was determined to be a forgery, written by the sportswriter who ghosted Cobb's autobiography. It was the smallest thing Al Stump did.Stump spent fifty years as a freelance writer and never broke through. Then, in 1961, he got the Cobb assignment — and five months after Cobb died, he published a magazine piece inventing a shotgun, a drunken deathbed, and a man beaten to death in a Detroit alley. Nineteen years later he was selling Cobb's possessions, including a shotgun. The Franklin County coroner's report says a pistol. Detroit's autopsy records contain no body. The eyewitness quoted in his 1994 biography died in 1956. And the record shows Stump spent no more than a few weeks with Cobb in total.This episode also follows how the invention became the standard account: reprinted in yearbooks and anthologies, then absorbed in 1984 by a careful academic biography that everyone else went on to cite.And it covers what got buried underneath: the hospital Cobb built in Royston in 1950, the scholarship foundation he created in 1953 and left a quarter of his estate — more than $21 million awarded since — and his request that the students never be told whose money it was.It refuses the easy correction, too. Cobb was violent, his violence fell hardest on Black men, and none of that needed inventing.Part two of two.IN THIS EPISODEThe forged diary in CooperstownCobb Memorial Hospital and the Ty Cobb Educational FoundationWhat he told the Associated Press about integration in 1952Who Al Stump was, and how little time he actually spent with CobbTrue magazine, December 1961, and the birth of the legendHow a fabrication became the standard biographyThe shotgun that never existed — and the one Stump soldThe killing that left no body, the Luger that wasn't there, Ted Williams's three-word answerFifty to a hundred forged letters in Cobb's green ink — and the duplicate that exposed himBarry Halper, the 1999 auction, and how the diary reached the Hall of FameWhy the correction can't go too farSOURCES "The Georgia Peach: Stumped by the Storyteller" by William R. Cobb, SABR, 2010. Franklin County coroner's report, August 9, 1905. The Sporting News, July 26, 1961. Sports Illustrated, 1995. Ty Cobb Educational Foundation. SABR BioProject. Mark Armour's review of Ty Cobb: A Terrible Beauty.DISCLAIMER Baseball Hall of Fame Lives is an independent production and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.KEYWORDS Ty Cobb, Al Stump, Barry Halper, baseball myths, forged memorabilia, Cooperstown, Hall of Fame, sports history, Royston Georgia, baseball biography, SABR
More episodes of Baseball Hall of Fame Lives
More episodes
- Christy Mathewson, Part Two: The Seven Rings
- Christy Mathewson, Part One: Two Views of Baker
- Honus Wagner The Tag That Wasn’t, Part 2
- Walter Johnson, Part Two: The Pebble
- Walter Johnson, Part One: The Train to Washington
- Honus Wagner, Part One: Some Yellow in Him
- Babe Ruth, Part Two: The House That He Built
- Babe Ruth, Part One: What He Was Worth
- Ty Cobb, Part One: The Trial and the Ballplayer
- Jeff Kent: More Home Runs Than Any Second Baseman
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.