Marta Wróblewska: From centre to (semi)periphery: policy-making in the area of research impact evaluation in UK, Poland and Norway
From RMZ Science Works · 00:37:10
Show by Robert K. Merton Zentrum für Wissenschaftsforschung
The talk will offer a comparative review of policy-making in the area of research impact evaluation in UK (REF), Poland (EJDD) and Norway (Humeval and Sameval). Poland and Norway have used an ex-post, expert-review system modeled on the British REF. There are several analogies between the studied impact evaluation systems, including similar definitions of impact, the use of case studies as the basis for evaluation, the structuring of the impact template and English as the language of evaluation. There are also several differences: the mode of introduction of the exercise (gradual vs. shift), whether the exercise is tied to funding, and the level of transparency of the policy-making and evaluation process. The text will present an overview of the three approaches on impact evaluation and attempt to answer the following question: 1) How does the articulation of research impact change depending on the goals of the exercise and the broader academic and social context into which the exercise is introduced; 2) Consequently, how do the effects of the exercise differ from one national context to another? After longer comparative part of the talk (based on an article submitted for review to Research Evaluation), I will attempt an interpretation of the ongoing process of policy-borrowing in the area of impact evaluation in terms of centre-periphery dynamics (as described by Immanuel Wallerstein) and/or Antonio Gramsci's theory of hegemony. The goal of the talk will be to test out theoretical theoretical perspectives on the data collected. I welcome any remarks and recommendations from the audience.
More episodes of RMZ Science Works
More episodes
- Sheena F. Bartscherer: Open Science, Venture Capital & the new Far Right
- Jacqueline Sachse: Nudging attention & shaping relevance. How citation rates influence academic literature assessment
- Thomas Wahl: Re-imagining humanness. Popular science narratives of AI futures
- Sven Arend Ulpts: From the Researcher to the Integrity of Knowledge Production
- Nicole Nelson: Reproducibility reforms in American biomedicine and the diffusion of the “regulatory ethos”
- Georgia Samaras: What’s it got to do with the brain? Challenges in doing clinical relevance in epigenetic research on mental health
- Dimity Stephen & Meta Cramer: Predatory publishing practices: Paper tigers or actual threats from evaluation systems?
- Olof Hallonsten: Stop evaluating science – a historical-sociological argument
- Anna Ahlers: China als neue Wissenschaftsmacht - soziologische Annäherungen
- Henning Laux: Dummheit – eine soziologische Kartographie
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.