Nicole Nelson: Reproducibility reforms in American biomedicine and the diffusion of the “regulatory ethos”
From RMZ Science Works · 00:47:15
Show by Robert K. Merton Zentrum für Wissenschaftsforschung
Recent scholarship has described the “reproducibility crisis” and its associated reform movement as a social movement or a scientific-intellectual movement. This talk will argue for an alternative framing of these events which de-emphasizes high-status intellectual actors and their agendas for change, and emphasizes instead structural aspects and how they shape which reforms come to be seen as possible and desirable. Taking this alternative lens, we could see the reproducibility movement not as a successful network of methodologists stitched together by Twitter and investment from private foundations, but as one instantiation of a broader diffusion of a “regulatory ethos” from highly regulated contexts into academic settings. Together with Lara Keuck, we describe the regulatory ethos as a specific type of scientific ethos (following Merton) that relies on documentation practices and favors plans over situated actions, uniformity over heterogeneity, and validation over external validity. Through a detailed history of the emergence of the reproducibility crisis in American biomedicine, I will show how pharmaceutical drug development and clinical medicine – two highly regulated spheres of practice – were key to providing the evidence and solutions that first generated support from key figures at the National Institutes of Health for reproducibility reform. From this I argue that this reform movement should be understood analytically as not merely an expression of the open science ideals of its most charismatic leaders, but as part of ongoing efforts to ensure the interoperability of experimental systems across distributed research spaces.
More episodes of RMZ Science Works
More episodes
- Sheena F. Bartscherer: Open Science, Venture Capital & the new Far Right
- Jacqueline Sachse: Nudging attention & shaping relevance. How citation rates influence academic literature assessment
- Thomas Wahl: Re-imagining humanness. Popular science narratives of AI futures
- Sven Arend Ulpts: From the Researcher to the Integrity of Knowledge Production
- Georgia Samaras: What’s it got to do with the brain? Challenges in doing clinical relevance in epigenetic research on mental health
- Marta Wróblewska: From centre to (semi)periphery: policy-making in the area of research impact evaluation in UK, Poland and Norway
- Dimity Stephen & Meta Cramer: Predatory publishing practices: Paper tigers or actual threats from evaluation systems?
- Olof Hallonsten: Stop evaluating science – a historical-sociological argument
- Anna Ahlers: China als neue Wissenschaftsmacht - soziologische Annäherungen
- Henning Laux: Dummheit – eine soziologische Kartographie
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.