Trump Asks SCOTUS to Curb Judges’ Power Over Agency Rules, Ecuadorean Fishermen Sue Over a Boat Strike & DOJ Warns Sen. Warren
From Minimum Competence · 8:09
Show by Andrew and Gina Leahey
This Day in Legal History: “I Am Not a Crook”On November 17, 1973, President Richard Nixon took questions from about 400 newspaper editors at a convention at Walt Disney World in Florida. Defending himself against the growing Watergate scandal, he said: “People have got to know whether or not their President is a crook. Well, I’m not a crook.” It became the most famous line of the scandal, mostly for how badly it aged.The context matters. It was less than a month after the Saturday Night Massacre, when Nixon fired Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox, and Attorney General Elliot Richardson and his deputy resigned rather than carry out the order. Just three days before the speech, on November 14, a federal judge ruled that Cox’s firing had been illegal. A new special prosecutor, Leon Jaworski, was pressing for the White House tapes, and the House had begun impeachment inquiries. Within months, the Supreme Court would unanimously order Nixon to turn over the tapes in United States v. Nixon, rejecting his claim of absolute executive privilege, and in August 1974 he resigned.The significance of November 17, 1973 is what it shows about accountability. A president’s denials don’t settle anything. The courts, Congress’s investigative power, and an independent prosecutor do. That system of checks, the power of judges to give effective relief, Congress’s power to investigate the executive, and the independence of prosecutors, is at issue in every one of today’s stories.The administration has asked the Supreme Court to further limit the power of federal judges, this time over agency regulations. Last year, in Trump v. CASA, the Supreme Court held that federal courts generally can’t issue “universal” injunctions blocking a policy for everyone, only relief needed to protect the plaintiffs. But the Court left open a different tool: the Administrative Procedure Act, which tells courts to “set aside” unlawful agency action. Courts have long read that to mean a rule found unlawful can be vacated entirely, so it no longer applies to anyone. Now the administration argues that even under the APA, courts should limit relief to the specific plaintiffs in the case and not wipe out a regulation nationwide. The case comes from a dispute over the federal rules implementing the No Surprises Act, the law protecting patients from surprise medical bills, a fight we’ve followed this year. In August, the Fifth Circuit upheld the nationwide invalidation of parts of those rules. The Justice Department filed its petition in October, and the Court is expected to decide early next year whether to take the case. Here’s why this matters so much. Vacatur under the APA has become one of the most important tools for challenging federal regulations, used by challengers on both the left and the right. Notably, Texas and Florida, along with other mostly Republican-led states, urged the Fifth Circuit to preserve it, because they’ve used it to strike down rules they opposed in other administrations. If the administration wins, a rule held unlawful in one case might keep applying to everyone else, forcing new lawsuits by each affected party. Supporters say that limits the outsized power of single district judges. Critics say it would mean the government could keep enforcing rules courts have already found illegal. Either way, it’s a question about the basic structure of judicial review of agencies.At the Supreme Court, Trump aims to cut the power of judges again | Reuters · Virginia Lawyers Weekly · IBTimesSixteen Ecuadorean fishermen have sued the U.S. government in federal court in Pittsburgh over a drone strike that destroyed their boat, the Negra Francisca Duarte II, in the Pacific in March, about 385 nautical miles off Ecuador’s coast. They allege the strike sank the boat and injured crew members, and that some of them were then held for about a day and mistreated. They’re seeking damages and a court order ending lethal strikes on boats in the Caribbean and Pacific. Some background. Since September 2025, the administration has carried out a campaign of military strikes on boats it says are operated by “narco-terrorists,” as part of what it calls Operation Southern Spear. The lawsuit says there have been 71 such strikes, killing at least 235 people. The government hasn’t claimed responsibility for this particular strike and says it has no information about it or two other Ecuadorean boats sunk this year. The Washington Post reported in August that these vessels were targeted as part of a CIA program. The White House and Justice Department didn’t immediately comment. These are allegations, and the case faces major legal obstacles. The Federal Tort Claims Act, which lets people sue the federal government for injuries, excludes claims arising in a foreign country and claims arising from combatant activities during wartime. The Supreme Court has also refused to let people sue federal officers directly for constitutional violations in cross-border cases…
More episodes of Minimum Competence
More episodes
- A Judge Orders the White House to Produce Its Big Law Deals & What “Rich” Should Mean in a Tax on the Rich
- Intel Faces a Securities Suit After a 29% Plunge, Jensen Huang Hires Paul Weiss & New York Wins Back Its Highway Funds
- Gibson Dunn Lands Weil’s 120-Lawyer Funds Team, the Senate Calls Jensen Huang and Howard Lutnick & SEC and CFTC Nominees Head to the Senate
- Remembering Judge Richard Posner & Alaska’s Ballot-Data Fight in the Last Uncalled Senate Race
- Weil’s Lawyers Scatter, Anthropic Faces a Suit Over Claude Max Marketing & the Paper Trail Behind Florida’s New Property Tax Cut
- A Defeated Texas Justice Heads for the Federal Bench, a Judge Halts Trump’s Arch & Legal Jobs Hit a Record High
- A Kentucky Law Professor’s Free-Speech Fight, Big Tech Sues Over California’s Youth Social Media Law & the Battle Over Trump’s Triumphal Arch
- Democrats Win Congress: What Divided Government Can and Can’t Do, Kraft Heinz Sells Maxwell House & the NYT Sues Brave
- SCOTUS Ends Trump’s Bid to Freeze California Ballots, a Judge Blocks Federal Noncitizen-Voter Lists & Why Refund-Heavy Tax Preparers Shouldn’t Be Red Flags
- Weil Gotshal Plans to Dissolve, the US Sues Google Over a Returning Reservist & the White House Press Fight Moves to the Oval Office
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.