A Judge Orders the White House to Produce Its Big Law Deals & What “Rich” Should Mean in a Tax on the Rich

From Minimum Competence · 6:51

Show by Andrew and Gina Leahey

This Day in Legal History: Goodridge v. Department of Public HealthOn November 18, 2003, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled, 4 to 3, that the state could not deny marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The case was brought by seven couples, represented by Mary Bonauto of Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, who had been turned away when they applied for licenses. Chief Justice Margaret Marshall’s majority opinion held that limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples lacked a rational basis under the Massachusetts Constitution, writing that the state constitution “forbids the creation of second-class citizens,” part of today’s opening quote.The court gave the legislature 180 days to respond. Massachusetts considered alternatives, including civil unions, but the court made clear that anything short of marriage wouldn’t satisfy its ruling. On May 17, 2004, Massachusetts became the first state to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The decision came under the state constitution, so it couldn’t be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.The significance of November 18, 2003 is that it began the legal path to Obergefell v. Hodges twelve years later, through state courts, legislatures, ballot measures, and federal appeals courts, including Judge Richard Posner’s opinion for the Seventh Circuit that we discussed last week. It’s also a lesson about definitions: much of the case turned on what the legal term “marriage” meant and whom it included. Definitions turn out to be at the heart of today’s column, too.A federal judge has ordered the White House to hand over records in the American Bar Association’s lawsuit over the administration’s campaign against law firms. U.S. District Judge Amir Ali ordered the government to produce the agreements it reached last year with nine major firms, including Kirkland & Ellis, Skadden, Latham & Watkins, Milbank, A&O Shearman, and Simpson Thacher, in which the firms pledged free legal work for causes the administration supports. He also ordered production of White House communications with those firms and with the smaller group of firms targeted by punitive executive orders, from the start of the President’s term through June 2025. Some of the deals’ terms have never been made fully public, and the communications could show how the executive orders and the agreements came about. The judge didn’t order everything disclosed. He said some, even many, of the records may be privileged, and the administration has refused to identify members of the press secretary’s “policy team,” citing presidential communications privilege. This is a significant ruling because discovery against the White House is unusual and handled carefully. The Supreme Court has said courts should be cautious about intrusive discovery directed at the President and his close advisers, and the presidential communications privilege protects advice given to the President. But United States v. Nixon held that privilege isn’t absolute and can yield to the needs of a legal proceeding. Ordering the agreements and communications to be produced, while leaving room for privilege claims over specific documents, is the kind of narrowing courts use to balance those interests. This connects to several stories we’ve covered this fall: the EEOC’s effort to keep its law firm investigation records secret, Paul Weiss’s deal with the administration coming up as Jensen Huang hired the firm, and Judge Ali’s earlier ruling against the counterterrorism-grant conditions. The firms’ deals have been among the most controversial episodes for the legal profession in years. Now we may learn more about how they were made.White House ordered to hand over records in lawsuit over Trump’s law firm crackdown | Reuters · Bloomberg Law · Above the LawAnd, in my column for Bloomberg Tax this week, I look at the “tax the rich” measures voters just endorsed. Colorado voters approved a graduated income tax with higher rates on income above $500,000, starting in 2027. Washington voters rejected an effort to repeal the state’s tax on income above $1 million. My argument is simple: if you’re going to tax the rich, you need a definition of “rich” that matches your intent, and that keeps matching it over time. The problem is inflation. Colorado’s new brackets, a 7.4% rate on income between $500,000 and $750,000 and higher rates above that, aren’t adjusted for inflation. Assume 3% inflation a year. After twenty years, a $500,000 income would have the purchasing power of about $277,000 today. To keep the threshold’s original value, the bracket would need to start around $903,000. So without indexing, the tax would gradually reach people whose real incomes are far below what voters had in mind. Whether people earning the equivalent of $277,000 today should pay a higher rate is a legitimate policy question, but it should be decided openly, not by letting inflation decide it quietly. Washington did index its $1 million threshold, which helps. But the…

More episodes of Minimum Competence

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.