Australian Federal Courts (18 November 2026)
From The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw · 9:17
Show by BarNet OpenLaw (JADE)
Send us Fan MailSix decisions in the Federal Courts edition for Wednesday 18 November 2026: one from the Full Court of the Federal Court and five from the Federal Court of Australia. The opening story: a contract claim founded on the same agreement as Fair Work Act claims is part of the same matter, and the Federal Court has no general discretion to decline it. Then the Full Court on particulars, directors' declarations and audit opinions in a securities class action, a company that wanted to run its case without a lawyer, a lease and the consumer law, and the registry. The Full Court ruling also features in today's Courts of Appeal brief.Practice and Procedure Desk (opening story).Liebovitz v Golden Steel International Pty Ltd t/a Ariston Wire [2026] FCA 1739 (Goodman J, 18 November 2026) - Signal: Practice and Procedure. A breach of contract claim for restraint payments joined with Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) claims (alleged sham contracting and employee entitlements, accepted as bona fide for the application) falls within the Federal Court's accrued jurisdiction where both arise from a common substratum of facts; the Agency Agreement was central to both, and employee status required consideration of all its terms. Once a non-federal claim is part of the matter, there is no discretion to decline it (abuse of process and forum non conveniens aside); relative quantum, costs regimes and evidence rules proceed on a false premise. Interlocutory application to strike out, stay or sever dismissed. JADECommercial Desk (the Full Court ruling).Davis v Wilson [2026] FCAFC 142 (Markovic, Sarah C Derrington and Bennett JJ, 18 November 2026) - Signal: Illustrative. A Part IVA shareholder class action over the fair value of sandalwood plantation assets. Appeal dismissed; cross-appeals allowed in part. Particulars that give content to a breach plea form part of the liability case; the counterfactual yield was not proved, and combining unreliable datasets did not make them reliable. The trial standard for the under-five yield forecast was too high. A collective unqualified directors' declaration under s 295(4) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) conveys that each approving director held the opinions, but reliance on internal expertise and external audit review gave the managing director reasonable grounds; the s 1041H finding against him was set aside. Audit opinions published with the financial reports are conduct "in relation to" the shares (an indirect connection suffices), but the auditor was not shown to lack reasonable foundation, and the negligence ground failed. A counterfactual not run at trial is unavailable on appeal; s 1041E has elements distinct from s 1041H. JADEPractice and Procedure Desk (a worked example).ACN 164 353 459 Pty Ltd v Rouholamin [2026] FCA 1744 (Longbottom J, 9 November 2026) - Signal: Illustrative. Dispensing with corporate legal representation under r 4.01(2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) via r 1.34: the seven-factor test from Dynamic Insurance Services Pty Ltd v Steadfast Group Limited [2026] FCA 964; incomplete tax returns and unparticularised loans were insufficient where bank statements showed funds; the capacity of those behind the company is relevant; protection orders and pending related criminal proceedings create an objectivity risk weighing against leave. Anyone facing a criminal charge is presumed innocent. JADECommercial Desk (a worked example).Mayur Resources Limited v Port Botany Operations Pty Ltd as Trustee for Port Botany Unit Trust [2026] FCA 1736 (Rangiah J, 18 November 2026) - Signal: Illustrative. Section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law applied to a commercial lease negotiation: whether a permitted use clause carries an implied representation; silence and non-disclosure; actual or constructive knowledge (public development plans, pleading admissions) defeating reliance; Jones v Dunkel inferences; reliance loss under s 236(1). JADERegistry (list only, no outcome stated).PDYY v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1735 (Markovic J, 18 November 2026) - judicial review. JADECopper Mines of Tasmania Pty Ltd v Gaspersic Contracting Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1712 (Neskovcin J, 13 November 2026) - pleadings. JADEFull typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.
More episodes of The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw
More episodes
- The Petal Investigates: The OpenLaw Files
- The Petals: The 2026 Law Nerd Awards
- Australian Fair Work (17 November 2026)
- Australian Courts of Appeal (18 November 2026)
- Australian Tribunals (18 November 2026)
- Australian Tribunals (17 November 2026)
- Australian Courts of Appeal (17 November 2026)
- Australian Federal Courts (17 November 2026)
- New Zealand Edition (17 November 2026)
- Australian Courts of Appeal (16 November 2026)
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.