Australian Courts of Appeal (18 November 2026)
From The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw · 17:18
Show by BarNet OpenLaw (JADE)
Send us Fan MailTen decisions from five appellate courts in the Court of Appeal edition of Wednesday 18 November 2026, with the New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, Western Australia, South Australia and Northern Territory editions of the same day folded in, and three decisions from the Victoria and South Australia collections of 17 November. Sexual offences are reported as legal doctrine only.Criminal Law Desk (opening story; doctrine only).Givens v R [2026] NSWCCA 191 - unreasonable verdict and the jury's advantage; post offence conduct not judged by preconceived notions; no fixed 'Ewen direction'; a warning resting only on lack of corroboration is barred by s 294AA(2) Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW); r 4.15 leave; s 165B(2) Evidence Act only on application. Appeal dismissed (Hamill, Rigg and Coleman JJ). JADEPractice and Procedure Desk (the murder trial is yet to be held; the accused is presumed innocent).Woollard (a pseudonym) v The King [2026] VSCA 277 - certification under s 295(3)(a) Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic); the low probative value dilemma. Review refused (Orr P, Donaghue JA). JADEHarrington v DPP [2026] VSCA 278 - bail pending a sentence appeal granted where a straight sentence would likely be served first (Kaye JA). JADESmith v DPP (Cth) [2026] VSCA 274 - reasonably arguable prospects are not exceptional circumstances; bail refused (Kaye JA). JADERe Application by Sef Gonzales [2026] NSWCCA 197 - a whole case referral to be dealt with as a sentence appeal does not open conviction grounds. Registrar confirmed (Hamill J). JADEPublic Law Desk.Liberty Holdings Australia Ltd v Greensill Capital (UK) Ltd (in administration) [2026] NSWCA 251 - open justice and inherent jurisdiction non-publication orders; consent declarations cannot be withheld like a private settlement. Stay not extended (Adamson JA). JADEMount Cottrell Properties Pty Ltd v Minister for Environment [2026] VSC 721 - 'satisfied on reasonable grounds' is stricter than legal unreasonableness; the grounds must rest on the Minister's own knowledge; s 8(1) Land Acquisition and Compensation Act 1986 (Vic) compliance essential. Acquisition declared invalid (Finanzio J). JADETrainor v Commonwealth of Australia [2026] SASC 158 - s 9 ADJR Act does not exclude State jurisdiction over debt and damages claims; collateral attack not always barred. Claim reinstated (Bochner J). JADECommercial Law Desk.Davis v Wilson [2026] FCAFC 142 - particulars can define the liability case; collective directors' declarations; reasonable grounds; audit opinions 'in relation to' shares. Appeal dismissed; cross-appeals allowed in part (Markovic, Sarah C Derrington and Bennett JJ; also Wednesday's Federal Courts edition). JADEBadat v Bp Australia Pty Ltd [No 3] [2026] WASC 504 - 'remediation' under the Contaminated Sites Act 2003 (WA) is not decontamination; no private nuisance where a lease governs the land's use or for a tenant's acts on the landlord's land; Hunt Leather followed. Claim dismissed (Howard J). JADERe Application by Li Shurong [2026] VSC 741 - international jurisdiction, habitual residence and citizenship; service by public announcement despite known electronic means denies natural justice. Registration refused (Steffensen AsJ). JADECriminal Law Desk (the Territory appeal as doctrine only).Catanuto v R [2026] NSWCCA 196 - agreed facts confine inferences; aggravating facts beyond reasonable doubt; remorse and cooperation; De La Rosa. Resentenced (Adamson JA, Lonergan and Roberts JJ). JADEBrown v R [2026] NSWCCA 194 - revoked interstate parole; Callaghan sets no mandatory considerations. Appeal dismissed (Mitchelmore JA, Sweeney and Boulten JJ). JADEThe King v McDougall [2026] NTCCA 14 - manifest inadequacy no more onerous than manifest excess; deportation and the residual discretion. Crown appeal allowed (Kelly, Blokland JJ, Riley AJ). JADERegistry (list only; no outcome stated; [2026] citations): GROW Technology Services NSWSC 1478 (scheme); Motio NSWSC 1468 (scheme); Perennial Enterprise NSWSC 1480 (winding up); Century City Corp v Bridge Bay Holdings NSWSC 1481 (security for costs); Chandra v Shree Sanatan Dharm Sabha of NSW (Costs) NSWSC 1378 (costs); AB v Cd (No 2) NSWSC 1483 (discovery); Archer Wealth v Buxton NSWSC 1476 (default judgment); PK Roofing v Zeta Build NSWSC 1465 (leave to appeal); Capital Securities Mortgages v Events By Lush (No 2) NSWSC 1479 (interlocutory); Etherington v North Sydney Council (No. 3) NSWLEC 1770 (modification); Derums v Inner West Council NSWLEC 1768 (modification); AKAT Investments v Mosman Municipal Council NSWLEC 1766 (development appeal); The Owners - Strata Plan No. 64730 v Council of the City of Sydney NSWLEC 1767 (environmental protection); Arbus Pottsville v Tweed Shire Council NSWLEC 149 (interlocutory); EPA v Wollongong Resources NSWLEC 146 (environmental sentencing); Turul Building Services v SKJ Qld QSC 276 (indemnity costs); Inteforge v Bhagwan Marine [No 3] WASC 502 (costs); R v Rigney (No…
More episodes of The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw
More episodes
- The Petal Investigates: The OpenLaw Files
- The Petals: The 2026 Law Nerd Awards
- Australian Fair Work (17 November 2026)
- Australian Federal Courts (18 November 2026)
- Australian Tribunals (18 November 2026)
- Australian Tribunals (17 November 2026)
- Australian Courts of Appeal (17 November 2026)
- Australian Federal Courts (17 November 2026)
- New Zealand Edition (17 November 2026)
- Australian Courts of Appeal (16 November 2026)
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.