Antisemitism, Islamophobia, and Abdul El-Sayed

From Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon · 13:38

Show by Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon

Last week’s midterm elections were a historic political realignment. They marked the end of the MAGA era and the beginning of something new, but one race more than any other is still on my mind. In Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed made history by handily defeating Mike Rogers to become the first Muslim-American elected to the Senate. There were a lot of extraordinary things about this race, from the mountain of money that AIPAC lit on fire trying to knock Abdul out early, to Haley Stevens, his vanquished primary opponent, torching her political career at the end. But the thing that I was tracking more than anything else was the weaponization of antisemitism and Islamophobia.One of the things that I do for work is educate people on the dangers of antisemitism and Islamophobia. I do this in partnership with my Muslim and Christian colleagues at Isma-Shema, and we go around the country giving presentations at universities, high schools, and conferences. We work hard to give people the tools to understand these social maladies and combat them in their communities. And let me tell you that nothing makes our job harder than politicians who casually and cynically invoke these bigotries for political gain. Let’s unpack some of what we saw and try to understand what it means about the culture that we inhabit.Abdul El-Sayed is unabashedly critical of the State of Israel, and this fact alone would have put him on a collision course with some of the Jewish community in Michigan. But the first real problem that he faced with regard to antisemitism came in March, after a terrorist named Ayman Ghazali drove a pickup truck into the front entrance of Temple Israel in West Bloomfield, Michigan. In a video statement posted to X in the immediate aftermath of the attack, El-Sayed condemned antisemitism and expressed sympathy for the parents of the Jewish children who were attending Temple Israel. He then went on to try and thread a very fine needle.“Violence is a cycle. Ayman Ghazali lost family, including two children, in an airstrike in Lebanon last week… Temple Israel is not the state of Israel. Jewish people are not the state of Israel, and the people of Israel are not the political actors who make direct choices for the State of Israel. We cannot and must not conflate these, an act rooted in antisemitism… Ayman Ghazali hurt people. There is no justification for what he did. It was wrong and he never should have done it. Hurt people. Hurt people. A week earlier, an airstrike killed his niece and nephew. Imagine if that had never happened. Imagine there was no war in Iran. Imagine if there were no airstrikes in Lebanon. Imagine if his family had never died. Imagine there was never an attack on Temple Israel. That’s the world that we want to live in. That’s the world we need to build for.”The line from this statement that El-Sayed’s opponents picked up and ran with, of course, was “Hurt people. Hurt people.” This statement led to a massive reaction that would haunt Abdul right up to the election last week. The criticism was that he was excusing or justifying the attack, or even that he was blaming Israel for it. I don’t know about you, but I don’t think there’s a good-faith way to read what he was saying in that way. I think the line that went viral was an insensitive choice of words, and Abdul would eventually apologize for it, but reading the whole thing back, I think that he was clearly trying to use the opportunity to educate people about the difference between Jews and Israel, and he even went out of his way to distinguish between Israeli citizens and the actions of their government. I think if he’s guilty of anything here, it’s choosing the wrong moment to try and thread that needle, and he admitted as much in his multiple public apologies for it.The other major accusation of antisemitism was the inciting incident that led Haley Stevens to endorse Mike Rogers 48 hours before the election. Cenk Uygur, the founder of The Young Turks, a popular left-wing YouTube channel, recycled a video ad from his failed 2024 presidential campaign and ran it in Michigan in the weeks before the election in support of Abdul El-Sayed. You see what is presumably a husband and wife having a conversation in the checkout aisle of a grocery store. Here’s the ad, and the key lines from it:Wife: No, they like eggs, but we have to set that $7 aside for killing Palestinians.Husband: What? I mean, don’t we give Israel $4 billion a year anyways?Wife: Yeah, and now we’re giving them another $26 billion…Husband: Don’t they get universal healthcare too?Wife: Yeah, they do. We’re paying for that too, probably. Might as well put the bananas back…Cenk: Why does Mike Rogers care so much about what Israelis want [graphic: ‘$228,808 spent by pro-Israel PACs to buy your senate seat’] and so little about what you want?… Mike Rogers is for [cough] they/them [an image of Benjamin Netanyahu, Bezalel Smotrich, and Itamar Ben-Gvir appears]. Abdul El-Sayed is for you.I’m…

More episodes of Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon

More episodes

PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.