And We Hold Our Breath
From Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon · 8:30
Show by Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon
The final polls for the Israeli election are in, and the results are (drum roll, please) inconclusive. Neither Netanyahu's coalition nor the Eisenkot-led opposition seems to have achieved an outright majority of the 120-seat Knesset, which means that, barring some dramatic polling error, we won't know the real outcome of the Israeli election for some time. In this liminal space, I want to take a moment to talk about what this election is not about.When Israelis go to vote on Tuesday, they will be voting on how they feel about Benjamin Netanyahu. They will be voting on what accountability for the security failures of October 7th should look like. And they will be voting on whether to draft the Haredim (ultra-Orthodox) into the IDF. But what they emphatically will NOT be voting on is Gaza, or Lebanon, or Iran. Why? Because there is widespread consensus in the Jewish-Israeli electorate on these issues, and that consensus is reflected in current Israeli policy. I say the Jewish-Israeli electorate because the one place in Israeli society where the consensus breaks down is the Arab minority. But the Arab citizens of Israel are second-class citizens, and though their parties run in elections, they are kept out of any ruling coalition by a racist gentlemen's agreement that has been broken only once, by the short-lived and largely ineffectual government of Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid.From the outside, this state of affairs is baffling. The outgoing government was in power on the worst day in Israeli history. It is responsible for the subsequent annihilation of Gaza and southern Lebanon and, at least in part, for the war with Iran. How is it possible that there is no debate inside Israel on the morality and wisdom of these consequential actions?Siege MentalityThe answer comes from an Israeli political psychologist named Daniel Bar-Tal, whom I had the pleasure of meeting and interviewing back in 2011. In his landmark paper "Beliefs About Negative Intentions of the World: A Study of the Israeli Siege Mentality," published in Political Psychology in 1992, Bar-Tal argued that Israelis hold a central belief that the rest of the world means them harm. The circumstances that led Israelis to adopt and maintain this mentality are no mystery: centuries of Jewish persecution culminating in the Holocaust, decades of wars with neighboring countries and armed conflict with the Palestinians, and international isolation. The features of siege mentality are as follows:* Strong pressure to conform* Deep distrust of outsiders and international bodies* Outside criticism read as hostility motivated by antisemitism* An emphasis on self-reliance* A readiness to take harsh measures in the name of self-defense, justified as "having no choice"* Very little room for internal dissentEretz Nehederet's Siren CallIn the season opener of Eretz Nehederet (Israel's Hebrew-language answer to SNL), we get a fascinating glimpse of the Israeli psyche at this precarious moment. The sketch is a take on the Odyssey, in which Odysseus is an IDF soldier trying to make his way home from an impossibly long rotation in the reserves. It's full of inside references to the election, but the part I want to bring to your attention is the scene with the sirens. Our hero is in a jeep with two fellow reservists, who put on noise-blocking headsets in anticipation of the sirens. The sirens turn out to be three half-human, half-snake creatures: Tally Gotliv, the far-right MK, and Yuval Abraham and his Naza co-director, Rachel Szor. Gotliv, who has been known to spread conspiracy theories about October 7th, shouts at them, "The IDF Chief of Staff knew! The pilots are traitors!" Abraham and Szor shout, "The pilots were murderers. You are Naza (Nazi) criminals!" Our hero, who refused the headset and chose instead to tie himself to the jeep, screams in agony from the back seat. Gotliv sees his pain and responds, "I'm not impressed. I can scream louder. Now I scream with Jewish Power!" (a reference to her defection from Likud to the Jewish Power party). She screams, and Abraham and Szor start clapping for her (a reference to the 25-minute standing ovation their documentary Naza received in Venice). "Enough! I want it to stop!" moans our hero. The driver replies, "Not happening, brother. It's at least another 20 to 25 minutes."There's a lot in this little scene. The average Israeli is a soldier just trying to survive long enough to get home. He is tormented from the right by conspiracy theorists who accuse the IDF of willful malpractice, and from the left by people calling him a Nazi war criminal. As comedians must, the writers of this sketch have located the everyman of Israeli society, and that everyman is absolutely incapable of processing moral criticism of his country's conduct in these wars, even when it comes from fellow Israelis.The Hard PartSo where does all of this leave those of us who care about the future of Israel/Palestine? Well, contrary to what many people…
More episodes of Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon
More episodes
- The Am Yisrael Chai Crowd, The Ideological Left, and The Rest of Us
- Antisemitism, Islamophobia, and Abdul El-Sayed
PodSearch is a free, independent podcast search engine. Read about PodSearch, the privacy policy or contact us.